S1E6 Small Town Tragedy
Kelly and Yolanda travel to Thatcher, AZ, to look for clues that may lead to resolution in the 1995 murder of a mother of two young children.
Episode Ratings Grid
Every episode at a glance, color-coded by rating. Rows are episode numbers within each season, columns are seasons.
M
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
E1
E2
E3
E4
E5
E6
E7
E8
E9
E10
E11
E12
E13
E14
E15
E16
E17
E18
E19
E20
E21
E22
E23
E24
E25
E26
Avg
Excellent
Great
Good
You Might Also Like
See AllEpisode Power Rankings
The best and worst episodes at a glance. Use this to find must-watch episodes or ones you might want to skip.
🏆 Top Episodes
#2
S2E9
Lady in the Box
Siegler and McClary head to Aurora, Colo.
#3
S2E10
Copper Dollar Ranch
Kelly and Yolanda land in Iowa to investigate a 1983 double murder.
- 4. S2E1 "Gone"
- 5. S2E8 "Billy Goat Hill"
- 6. S1E5 "Hiding in Plain Sight"
- 7. S1E8 "Blind Love"
- 8. S2E5 "He Said, He Said"
- 9. S2E6 "Ambush"
- 10. S2E7 "Single Working Mom"
📉 Bottom Episodes
#132
S7E3
Killer at the Door
Kelly and Steve join the Kankakee Police Department to help a woman who just missed seeing her mother's killer at their front door when she was 11 years old. Decades later, can she recall any clues to help crack the case?
- 131. S6E7 "A Desperate Father"
- 130. S7E5 "Some Kind of Monster"
- 129. S6E12 "Three Generations Gone"
- 128. S7E6 "The Reporter"
The Quality Arc
Each point is an episode, plotted chronologically. The colored bands mark season boundaries. Look for upward or downward trends to see if quality improved or declined over time.
Episode Engagement
Vote count shows how many people cared enough to rate. High votes + high rating = beloved classic. High votes + low rating = notorious stinker. Low votes + high rating = hidden gem.
Rating threshold:
66 Standouts
1 Infamous
55 Hidden Gems
10 Forgettable
Top Standout: S1E1 Small Town Suicide?
Most Infamous: S6E1 Holiday Homicide
Best Hidden Gem: S5E25 A Family's Nightmare
Episodes plotted by rating vs. vote count. The vertical line marks the rating threshold (7.5). More votes = more engagement. Toggle above to compare against global or show-specific median.
Series Trajectory
A simplified view: one point per season. This smooths out episode-to-episode noise to show the overall arc of the series.
Season Momentum
Did each season build momentum or fizzle out? Green arrows mean the finale rated higher than the premiere. Red means the opposite. Longer arrows = bigger swings.
Season Consistency
Some seasons are reliable bangers. Others are hit-or-miss. Each dot is an episode. Tightly clustered dots mean consistent quality. Scattered dots mean a mixed bag.
Each dot is an episode. Clustered dots = consistent quality. Scattered dots = variable season. Hover for episode details.